Showing posts with label political. Show all posts
Showing posts with label political. Show all posts

11 November 2008

love and marriage

(i've debated with myself about whether or not i should post this here, primarily because i don't want to propogate a political debate on my blog, but i feel strongly enough about the issue and want to get some knowledge and thoughts out there. if you'd rather not read this, that's fine. yes, it's about prop 8.)

i read an article today that expressed well a few ideas that i have had rolling around in my head. whereas this article doesn't articulate everything rolling around in my head, the author explains clearly a few key points. here are some excerpts from the article:

"The debate over whether the state ought to recognize gay marriages has thus far focused on the issue as one of civil rights. Such a treatment is erroneous because state recognition of marriage is not a universal right. States regulate marriage in many ways besides denying men the right to marry men, and women the right to marry women. Roughly half of all states prohibit first cousins from marrying, and all prohibit marriage of closer blood relatives, even if the individuals being married are sterile. In all states, it is illegal to attempt to marry more than one person, or even to pass off more than one person as one’s spouse. Some states restrict the marriage of people suffering from syphilis or other venereal diseases. Homosexuals, therefore, are not the only people to be denied the right to marry the person of their choosing.

"I do not claim that all of these other types of couples restricted from marrying are equivalent to homosexual couples. I only bring them up to illustrate that marriage is heavily regulated, and for good reason. When a state recognizes a marriage, it bestows upon the couple certain benefits which are costly to both the state and other individuals. Collecting a deceased spouse’s social security, claiming an extra tax exemption for a spouse, and having the right to be covered under a spouse’s health insurance policy are just a few examples of the costly benefits associated with marriage. In a sense, a married couple receives a subsidy ...

"Some argue that homosexual marriages serve a state interest because they enable gays to live in committed relationships. However, there is nothing stopping homosexuals from living in such relationships today. Advocates of gay marriage claim gay couples need marriage in order to have hospital visitation and inheritance rights, but they can easily obtain these rights by writing a living will and having each partner designate the other as trustee and heir. There is nothing stopping gay couples from signing a joint lease or owning a house jointly, as many single straight people do with roommates. The only benefits of marriage from which homosexual couples are restricted are those that are costly to the state and society ...

"The biggest danger homosexual civil marriage presents is the enshrining into law the notion that sexual love, regardless of its fecundity, is the sole criterion for marriage. If the state must recognize a marriage of two men simply because they love one another, upon what basis can it deny marital recognition to a group of two men and three women, for example, or a sterile brother and sister who claim to love each other? Homosexual activists protest that they only want all couples treated equally. But why is sexual love between two people more worthy of state sanction than love between three, or five? When the purpose of marriage is procreation, the answer is obvious. If sexual love becomes the primary purpose, the restriction of marriage to couples loses its logical basis, leading to marital chaos."

i think we forget in all of this hype that is currently taking over my tv and my city that marriage is not a civil right and was never purported to be. love whomever you choose: there is no legal restriction on that. but align yourself to the notion that the definition of marriage does not encompass all love relationships.

06 November 2008

oh, honestly ...

i just got the following email message from my stake:

"Due to protesters, the Los Angeles Temple was closed this evening.
They ask that before coming in tomorrow you call first to see if they will be open.
"

that's disappointing.

on the news last night, they showed the marches that were happening in santa monica/hollywood until late in the evening.

i read that there have already been lawsuits brought with the primary premise being that this matter was fundamental enough to require not only a constitutional amendment but a constitutional revision and that such action requires a 2/3 passage in the state congress before it can be brought for a popular vote. we'll see what comes of that.

we live in a country where we are free to do so many things, including vote. and yet there are those who would wish to take that vote away when its results oppose their point of view.

those who are requesting tolerance, do not tolerate. those who speak of rights, do not recognize the rights of others.

i have mixed feelings.

part of me has a knee-jerk reaction that they are just being poor losers. at the same time, i don't imagine that they are feeling very differently than others who are refused something that is so important to them. i am disappointed, however, that they do not behave with the respect that they themselves desire.

28 October 2008

electoral

*this* is why my vote won't matter in this presidential election:

(this map was put together by liz green for her blog post, "looking for the magic number 270? turn your eyes to the state polls" for yahoo news.)

as many of us may not remember, the presidency is not decided by popular vote. it's decided by the electoral college. we vote on nov-4; they vote on dec-15 this year. the candidate who gets a majority of the electoral college votes wins, so we really only need to be concerned with what collection of states a candidate can put together to get to 270 (a simple majority; there are 538 total electoral college votes divvied up among the states as shown above).

which then just becomes a math game ...

(i know, "math" and "game" aren't usually used together in a sentence, and certainly don't usually denote anything fun ... but stick with me here.)

okay. come tuesday, i won't actually be voting for obama or mccain, i will be voting for my state's electors. california has 55 electors in the electoral college, the most of any state.

according to wikipedia, "electors are technically free to vote for anyone eligible to be president, but in practice pledge to vote for specific candidates and voters cast ballots for favored presidential and vice presidential candidates by voting for correspondingly pledged electors. ... the ticket that receives the most votes statewide 'wins' all of the votes cast by electors from that state."

what does that mean? except for in two states in the union, each state's electors are all or nothing. which means that whichever ticket wins a majority of the popular vote in the state, wins all of that state's electoral votes. so ... whichever ticket wins a majority of the popular vote in california, wins all 55 electoral votes. as few as 50% of the california population plus 1 person can vote blue and all 55 of my state's electoral votes go blue. hmmm.

which is why my state has usually been blue and will probably be blue for the foreseeable future. the same is true of states like utah (whose 5 votes almost always go red), texas (whose 34 votes also usually go red), and new york (whose 31 votes usually go blue).

as you can see, unless you live in one of the "swing states" (which are denoted as grey in the map above, and this year they are colorado, florida, indiana, missouri, nevada, new mexico, north carolina, ohio, pennsylvania, virginia, and new hampshire), the decision is generally already made for you. i hope you swing staters realize this and get out and vote; make your voice heard.

my intention is not to encourage a lack of participation in our country's election, nor an indifference or sense of disempowerment. i am frustrated with the way the system works. i can believe that when the electoral college was set up, it was necessary in order to conduct an efficient and effective election that provided for the interests of both the individual citizen and the states. i don't believe we need it now. i believe that we do not so much define ourselves as citizens of states, but as citizens of this country. i believe that the electoral college represents better the voices of states over the voices of individual citizens because i believe the system as it is now blocks my voice from being heard at all.

...

and i know that unless obama, mccain, and all the 538 members of the senate and the house of representatives read my blog and think i actually know something of which i speak, none of this ranting will matter. but i just can't hold it in any longer!

don't think less of me.

:P

please note that, yes, i am going to vote. despite all these frustrations, i believe that we should vote. i have already received my absentee ballot, which i am going to mail in tomorrow. as my mom always says, "if you don't vote, you don't have room to complain". and i like to complain! ha!

(ps -- if anyone has input or enlightenment to share with me as the necessity of the electoral college and the purpose for its existence in our nation today, i would really like to discuss. really.)

27 October 2008

yes

in case anyone is looking for some info online about prop 8 here in california, here's a collection of vidoes and stuff i just got in an email. with the upcoming election, i thought i'd get this out there for anyone interested ...

yes on 8 youtube videos

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI-GjWY-WlA -- this is one of the best: proposition 8 in plain english (especially good for kids... and adults)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4kKn5LNhNto -- 1st ad from protectmarriage.com (gavin newsom)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PgjcgqFYP4 -- 2nd ad from protectmarriage.com (i can marry a princess)

https://www.icontribute.us/protectmarriage/initiative/schools-web -- 3rd ad from protectmarriage.com (it's all about schools)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l2JOe04h1pI -- ad showing the slippery slope of how marriage becoming everything to everyone will make marriage nothing to anyone

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ko2-EQss0V4 -- party a & party b spoof ad

http://link.brightcove.com/services/player/bcpid1815820715?bctid=1822459319
-- frc mini documentary on the parkers in massachusetts

http://link.brightcove.com/services/player/bcpid1352578267?bctid=1784553601
-- frc on black race vs. sexual preference

http://link.brightcove.com/services/player/bcpid1352578267?bctid=1784521903
-- frc parkers and wirthlin on massachusetts gay education

http://link.brightcove.com/services/player/bcpid1352578267?bctid=1749436976
-- frc about the importance of voting

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puI4pfRB0w0 -- parkers in massachusetts

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xx-glEL5SHE -- uk warns us "don't follow our lead"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDwIy3mT1Po -- vote "yes to proposition 8" (same sex marriage) / part 1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXjrULY3RMw -- vote "yes to proposition 8" (same sex marriage) / part 2

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MsiZ3crfXXc -- vote "yes to proposition 8" (same sex marriage) / part 3

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aeUJd4y87iU -- support prop 8 - newt gingrich on judicial tyranny

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mjC4lQ90Sas -- governor romney on gay marriage

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8EwbEh8EKo -- catholic bishop speaks in support of prop 102 (arizona)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_V76Gbrpys -- tom minnery of focus on the family introduces glenn stanton

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iZk5lew9vMA -- glenn stanton preface to his 10 questions and talks about how to engage this issue

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sL2MJ6hah-I -- glenn stanton question 1: how will my same-sex marriage hurt your marriage?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p81mkYOtJMU -- glenn stanton question 2: is same-sex marriage like interracial marriage?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEL0f2yuqLo -- glenn stanton question 3: where does it stop?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dF6w2ILsyUA -- glenn stanton question 4: can't we have religious marriage and civil marriage?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t9cYmAGbREA -- glenn stanton question 5: what public good does marriage provide?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5QYnJwQttQ -- glenn stanton question 6: is it healthy to experiment with children?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8P3x0UsTNQ -- glenn stanton question 7: haven't experts said same-sex parenting is fine?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tx3IqxKFCp4 -- glenn stanton question 8: how do we know what kind of families kids need?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOJdIQbGIE -- glenn stanton question 9: are the needs of kids or adults more important?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9YmONdhwXCg -- glenn stanton question 10: does gender really matter?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aiX5APGCroU -- young adult video shown during prop 8 fireside with elders ballard, cook & clayton

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ewXaVmfOj2w -- elder nelson on marriage

http://www.preservingmarriage.org/videos.html -- lds church's multi-media site on prop 8. this has lots of really good videos from church members

http://www.lds.org/ldsnewsroom/media/mediaplayer.swf?media=http://broadcast.lds.org/newsroom/video/flv/California_Broadcast_8Oct08.flv&type=FLV -- excerpts from the proposition 8 broadcast for california latter-day saints, october 8, 2008

websites

- http://www.blogger.com/www.ProtectMarriage.com

- http://www.blogger.com/www.Focusonsocialissues.org

- http://www.blogger.com/www.JohnRankin.org

- http://www.blogger.com/www.Standformarriage.com